1. TWO LABELS, BOTH SAYING 1,000 MG
Pick up two magnesium products. Both show 1,000 mg in large print. One delivers around 140 mg of actual magnesium. The other might deliver 250 mg, or more. Nothing about the headline figure tells you which is which.
Minerals can't be put into a supplement on their own. Pure magnesium or zinc isn't stable enough, so each mineral is bound to a carrier molecule. The finished ingredient, mineral plus carrier, is called a compound.
That gives every mineral two possible numbers: the weight of the whole compound, and the weight of the mineral inside it. Think of the compound as a delivery truck and the mineral as its cargo. Many labels lead with the weight of the whole truck. Your body only uses the cargo.
The biggest number on the label is often the one that matters least.
2. HOW MUCH MINERAL IS IN EACH FORM
The share of actual mineral in a compound depends on the carrier, and it's fixed by chemistry:
- Magnesium bisglycinate: about 14% magnesium.
- Magnesium oxide: about 60% magnesium.
- Zinc gluconate: about 14% zinc.
- Zinc bisglycinate: roughly 25 to 30% zinc.
- Zinc citrate: about 31% zinc.
- Zinc oxide: about 80% zinc.
- Calcium carbonate: about 40% calcium.
- Calcium citrate: about 21% calcium.
So 500 mg of magnesium bisglycinate supplies around 70 mg of magnesium.
The catch with cheap forms
Oxide forms pack the most mineral into each gram, which is why they're cheap and common. They're also poorly absorbed. Magnesium oxide delivers less to your body than better-absorbed forms [1], and zinc oxide is absorbed less well than zinc citrate or gluconate [2].
Calcium is a milder case. Carbonate absorbs best when taken with a meal, while citrate absorbs well either way.
The same applies beyond minerals
Plenty of performance ingredients come as compounds too. Citrulline malate is typically two parts citrulline to one part malic acid, so 6 g of citrulline malate supplies about 4 g of citrulline. When comparing products, check whether the dose is citrulline itself or citrulline malate. The same goes for choline bitartrate, which is only about 40% choline.
3. FOUR WAYS TO LABEL THE SAME THING
UK law requires the actual amount of each vitamin and mineral to be declared on a food supplement [3]. So the number you need is always on there somewhere.
The problem is that brands present it in very different ways. Here are four layouts taken from real magnesium products:
- Mineral first: "Magnesium (as bisglycinate) 200 mg, 53% NRV." The headline number is the magnesium you get. This is the clearest format.
- Compound first: "Magnesium bisglycinate 300 mg, of which magnesium 60 mg." Everything is there, but the big number is the one that matters least.
- Two columns: "Magnesium bisglycinate 1,000 mg | Elemental magnesium 250 mg." Fine if you read the right column. Most people will see 1,000.
- Upside down: "Magnesium 151.2 mg, of which magnesium bisglycinate 1,375 mg." The "of which" figure is nine times bigger than the total it's supposedly part of.
All four show the magnesium figure somewhere. Only one makes the real dose obvious at a glance.
The dose you get is always on the label. It just isn't always the number printed biggest.
4. HOW TO READ A MINERAL LABEL
Four steps get you the real figure every time.
Find the form
It's usually in brackets after the mineral, as part of the ingredient name, or in a line underneath. Oxide, carbonate, citrate, gluconate, bisglycinate and picolinate are the common ones.
Work out what the number refers to
"Magnesium (as bisglycinate) 200 mg" means 200 mg of magnesium. "Magnesium bisglycinate 500 mg" means 500 mg of compound. If a sub-line says "of which magnesium" or there's an "elemental" column, that's your figure.
Check the maths
Use the percentages in Section 2 to sanity-check. 500 mg of magnesium claimed from 500 mg of bisglycinate is impossible. You'd need over 3 g of compound.
The maths can also tell you what's really inside. Pure bisglycinate is about 14% magnesium. If a product's magnesium works out far higher than 14% of the stated bisglycinate weight, treat it as a red flag: it almost certainly contains a cheaper form as well. "Buffered" bisglycinate, for example, is often blended with magnesium oxide, which raises the magnesium per gram but is poorly absorbed [1].
Compare like with like
Convert every product to the actual mineral amount before comparing. A label reading "Magnesium bisglycinate 1,000 mg" looks five times stronger than one reading "Magnesium (as bisglycinate) 200 mg". In actual magnesium, the second delivers more.
5. ADDING UP YOUR DAILY TOTAL
When you total a nutrient across your stack, use the actual mineral amount from each product, never the compound weight. Add up headline figures and you can think you're getting several times more magnesium or zinc than you really are.
Then factor in the form. A total built mostly from oxides delivers less than the same figure from well-absorbed forms. ENG-A013 covers how to check your full daily picture.
6. TWO GAPS BETWEEN THE LABEL AND YOUR BODY
Every mineral dose has two gaps to cross. The first is between the compound weight and the mineral inside it. The second is between the mineral you swallow and the amount your body absorbs.
Reading the label properly closes the first gap. Choosing well-absorbed forms narrows the second. Do both and the number you're relying on is as close as a label can get you to what your body receives.
Read the form, find the real mineral figure, then compare. Every time.
REFERENCES
[1] Firoz M, Graber M. Bioavailability of US commercial magnesium preparations. Magnes Res. 2001;14(4):257-262.
[2] Wegmüller R, Tay F, Zeder C, Brnic M, Hurrell RF. Zinc absorption by young adults from supplemental zinc citrate is comparable with that from zinc gluconate and higher than from zinc oxide. J Nutr. 2014;144(2):132-136.
[3] Directive 2002/46/EC on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to food supplements, Article 8 (as retained in UK law).